Leadership, Loyalty & Lessons: What Kohl’s CEO Shake-Up Tells Us About Business Ethics

In a stunning move this week, the retail giant abruptly terminated CEO Ashley Buchanan after just a few months in the role. The reason? An internal investigation uncovered vendor transactions tied to undisclosed conflicts of interest, including a relationship with a romantic partner.

Oof.

According to The Wall Street Journal, the transactions involved companies connected to Buchanan’s former partner, raising serious red flags around ethics, transparency, and executive accountability. While full details remain under wraps, the fallout has already begun. Buchanan is out. Equity awards gone. Re-election withdrawn. Interim CEO Michael Bender is stepping in while the company regroups—again.

Let’s be clear: this isn’t just drama. This is about leadership trust and brand credibility.

What This Means for Kohl’s (and Everyone Watching)

Kohl’s has been fighting an uphill battle, store closures, job cuts, and sluggish sales. Now it’s dealing with its fourth CEO in three years and another blow to its reputation. Investors might be relieved to see accountability in action, but the instability doesn’t inspire long-term confidence.

From a brand and leadership perspective, this situation is a case study in what not to do:

✅ Ethical blind spots at the top can erode trust from the inside out.
✅ Vendor transparency must be non-negotiable.
✅ Culture eats policy for breakfast, if the culture doesn’t support ethical clarity, the policy doesn’t stand a chance.

And yes, even in moments of chaos, Kohl’s shares actually rose over 8% after the news broke. But don’t mistake relief for recovery. Real trust takes longer to rebuild than it does to spike on Wall Street.

The Bigger Takeaway

This isn’t just about Kohl’s. It’s a wake-up call to every brand trying to do business with heart and integrity.

Whether you're running a retail chain or a creative agency, people are paying attention to how you lead, especially when no one’s watching. Brand reputation isn’t built in campaign launches or flashy product drops. It’s built in the boardroom. In procurement. In how you handle conflicts of interest when they arise.

So here’s the real question: Does your leadership culture encourage integrity, or quietly reward shortcuts?

Because when the pressure’s on, the cracks will show.

‍